Sherbin Fellowship Application Review

Please use this form to submit your rankings and feedback of Sherbin Fellowship applicants. Submit one form per applicant. You are able to save and continue your form, so you don’t have to complete it all in one sitting. After submission, you will receive a copy of your responses via email for your reference. Thank you so much for your careful reading and thoughtful feedback!

Reviewer Last Name(Required)
This will allow me to confirm submission and send you a copy of your notes for your reference.
Applicant Last Name(Required)

Personal Evaluation

Please score and provide constructive feedback for each category to guide selection discussions. This section evaluates the personal qualities of the applicant. The individual nature of this fellowship requires a fellow with an extraordinary level of independence, flexibility, adaptability and communication skills.
Does the applicant demonstrate leadership skills?
Not enough info12345
Has the applicant shown ownership in their work or community?
Not enough info12345
Has the applicant exhibited honest and principled behavior?
Not enough info12345
When faced with difficult personal challenges, how has the applicant responded?
Not enough info12345
Does the applicant show they think beyond the boundaries they are given?
Not enough info12345
Does the applicant demonstrate that they can carve a personal path to a meaningful end?
Not enough info12345
Does the applicant deal effectively with problems when resources are scarce?
Not enough info12345
Does the applicant show they persevere under moral, emotional, and physical challenges?
Not enough info12345

Project Evaluation

Please score and provide constructive feedback for each category to guide selection discussions. This section evaluates the qualities of the proposed project. Feasibility is key!
The project must grow from the candidate’s background, their interests, activities, and themes that they have shown active engagement in.
Not enough info12345
It must be deeply meaningful to their life and will provide the energy to sustain and propel them through the ups and downs of the year.
Not enough info12345
The project should take advantage of the fellowship’s unique latitude, its flexibility and permission to stay curious and even fail.
Not enough info12345
Provided the project is realistic, the candidates should push the envelope to stretch.
Not enough info12345
The project must balance boldness with pragmatism.
Not enough info12345
Applicants are encouraged to reach out to inspiring institutions and organizations.
Not enough info12345
The project should include multiple approaches via methods, disciplines, and/or borders.
Not enough info12345
Please share any comments or concerns you have about the proposed budget.
Please share any other comments or feedback that did not fit in a previous category.